Karamella Consulting

Solving & Defining

Below are four matters, described without identifying details. Each shows the question I was asked, what I did, and what my work established. Of course, legal outcomes rest with counsel and the courts. These accounts describe my scientific contribution only.

01

Scientific Investigation · Food and Beverage · Recall

Something floating in the iced tea.

Problem

A major restaurant chain reported visible material floating in bottled iced tea from a beverage manufacturer. Counsel needed to know quickly what it was, whether it was dangerous, and how exposed the company was.

What I did

I had the material analysed and identified as a toxic fungus. I advised an immediate recall of the affected lot, then sent a sampling team through the bottling plant, swabbing every step of the process.

Outcome

We found where the fungus was entering – and a faulty capper that let air in and allowed it to grow. The recall was limited to the affected lot. The client had a clear remediation plan and a defensible account of the cause.

02

Scientific Investigation · Cause of Death

The tonic under the sink.

Problem

A coroner had ruled a man's death a suicide. His family didn’t believe the finding and suspected poisoning. The man had consumed a homemade herbal tonic every day. The family’s lawyer contacted me to find out the truth.

What I did

I had the tonic and the coroner's stored blood sample sent to a forensic laboratory and screened for approximately 250 drugs and toxins.

Outcome

Both contained high concentrations of an antidepressant he had never been prescribed, at levels that could plausibly have killed him. The finding gave the family's counsel scientific grounds to question the original ruling.

03

Expert Witness · Criminal · Ontario Court

One blood sample, taken hours later.

Problem

Defence counsel needed to know whether an accused person was impaired at the moment of a serious incident captured on video. The only evidence was a single blood sample taken at hospital, hours afterward.

What I did

I compared the measured drug concentrations with her behaviour on video and the scientific literature on impairment at those levels.

Outcome

I gave the opinion that the concentrations were consistent with the impairment shown in the footage. I was equally clear about the limits: with one sample, the concentration at the time of the incident could only be estimated, not established.

04

Expert Witness · Pesticides · Federal Tribunal

A pesticide before a federal Board of Review.

Problem

After Health Canada's Pest Management Regulatory Agency ended the registrations of lindane products, the Minister of Health established an independent Board of Review to examine the decision.

What I did

I gave expert evidence to the Board on the use of uncertainty factors in toxicity risk assessment calculations.

Outcome

The Lindane Review Board concluded that the PMRA’s risk assessment was highly flawed both scientifically and procedurally, partially based on my testimony.